Lease vs Buy: Find Your Car Break-Even Point (2026)
Written by Jordan Lee, Editor · Last updated July 21, 2026 · Fact-checked based on public sources as of this date
Leasing usually wins on cash flow over 2-3 years, but buying almost always wins on total cost if you keep the car past the loan term — once you’re driving it payment-free while a leaser is still paying monthly, the math flips hard in favor of buying. Enter your numbers below to see your actual break-even point.
Break-even calculator
This compares total cash outflow for leasing versus buying over a period you choose, accounting for the resale value you’d keep if you bought instead.
| Input | What it means |
|---|---|
| Lease monthly payment | What you’d pay per month to lease |
| Loan monthly payment | What you’d pay per month financing a purchase |
| Down payment (buy) | Upfront cash if you buy — leases often need less upfront |
| Years you’ll keep the car | How long you actually plan to drive it |
| Estimated resale value at that point | What you could sell it for if you own it outright |
Enter your numbers to see total cost under each option.
When we ran this ourselves for a common scenario — a 3-year lease versus a 5-year loan, keeping the car 6 years total — buying won by a wide margin, mostly because the last year of ownership was payment-free while a lease renewal would have started a whole new payment cycle.
Why the break-even point shifts so much by situation
The single biggest variable is how long you actually keep the car after the loan or lease term ends. If you always trade in the moment a lease is up, leasing’s predictable costs and lower upfront commitment can genuinely make sense — you’re comparing apples to apples with a new lease each cycle, never carrying old-car maintenance risk.
But the math shifts hard the moment you keep a purchased car even one year past the loan payoff. That’s a year of zero car payment against a lease that’s still costing you $300-500 a month, and it’s this stretch of ownership that usually decides the comparison.
Questions that matter more than the math
How many miles do you actually drive? Leases cap annual mileage (commonly 10,000-15,000 miles) with real per-mile penalties for going over — if your commute or lifestyle regularly exceeds that, leasing gets expensive fast in ways the sticker payment doesn’t show.
Do you want to be making car payments indefinitely? Serial leasers effectively never stop paying for a car. If your goal is eventually driving without a monthly payment at all, buying (and keeping the car after payoff) is the only path that gets you there.
- The longer you keep a car after paying it off, the more buying wins
- Check your actual annual mileage against lease limits before committing
- Add maintenance and insurance cost differences for a complete picture
- A used car purchase often beats both new-car lease and new-car buy on pure cost
FAQ
Q: Is insurance cheaper for a leased car?
Usually not — leasing companies typically require higher liability coverage than state minimums, which can make leased-car insurance slightly more expensive than an owned car with the same coverage level.
Q: Can I negotiate a lease price like I would a purchase?
Yes — the vehicle’s negotiated “cap cost” works the same as a purchase price negotiation and directly affects your monthly lease payment, so don’t skip negotiating just because you’re leasing.
Q: What about buying out my lease at the end?
This can work well if the buyout price is below the car’s actual market value, effectively letting you buy at a discount — check the buyout price against comparable used listings before deciding.
Q: Does a bigger down payment change which option wins?
Yes, but less than most people assume. A larger down payment lowers your monthly loan payment either way, but it doesn’t change the fundamental math of buying eventually being payment-free versus leasing never being payment-free. It shifts the timeline slightly rather than the underlying conclusion.
Debt Snowball vs Avalanche: Which Payoff Order Wins
If a car payment is one of several debts you’re juggling, it’s worth running the numbers through our debt payoff order calculator to see where it fits in your overall priority list.
